European Commission - Speech [Check Against Delivery] Commissioner Roswall's opening speech at the EPP Group Hearing, ‘From Stress Test to Solutions – Practical Lessons for the Birds and Habitats Directives' Brussels, 19 November 2026 Dear Norbert, Honourable Members, ladies and gentlemen, I am delighted to join you today. Let me begin by thanking the EPP Group for organising this hearing on our Nature Directives. Th...
European Commission - Speech [Check Against Delivery] Commissioner Roswall's opening speech at the EPP Group Hearing, ‘From Stress Test to Solutions – Practical Lessons for the Birds and Habitats Directives' Brussels, 19 November 2026 Dear Norbert, Honourable Members, ladies and gentlemen, I am delighted to join you today. Let me begin by thanking the EPP Group for organising this hearing on our Nature Directives. This issue is vital to our economy and environment. To citizens, civil society and climate resilience. To food security, farmers, foresters, fishers and the future of our society. Already last year we agreed on doing a stress test of the Nature Directives, which is now approaching its final stages. The review of the Directives, announced in the Commission's work programme for 2027, will assess whether legal changes are needed. We need to ensure that the directives function effectively and achieve their objectives in a simple way. And we have reached a point where reflection, evidence, science and practical experience must come together. That is exactly why debates like this are so important. When we discuss Europe's nature legislation, we are not discussing abstract or theoretical rules. We are discussing how the Nature Directives are implemented in practice. We are discussing life, lives and livelihoods. And we are discussing how we ensure that Europe remains ambitious on biodiversity and attentive to the realities on the ground - in our rural areas, in our forests, on farmland, along our coasts, and in the places where people live, work, manage land and depend on nature. I have had these conversations with farmers, foresters and others across Europe – in Baden and Budapest. In the north of Portugal and the south of Sweden. I have heard the real-life concerns. And I know that these questions lie at the very centre of our quest for food, energy and climate security, for greater competitiveness, for health and for a resilient, prosperous future. Nature is a cornerstone of our economic security. It provides the water, soils, pollination, flood protection and other ecosystem services on which our businesses and economies depend. The European Central Bank estimates that 7 out of 10 European companies are critically dependent on at least one ecosystem service. 75% of bank loans are tied to these businesses. And recent research by the ECB estimates that water scarcity alone could put a quarter of the euro area's economic output at risk. So, nature degradation is a threat to our economy and competitiveness. To our small businesses and big industries. This was very clear last summer. Drought, heatwaves, and wildfires reminded us that climate and nature are not separate from our economies. They are embedded deeply within them. This brings me to a guiding principle at the very core of my portfolio. Protecting nature and strengthening our economy are not opposing objectives. They are mutually reinforcing. So, the question is not whether nature protection is necessary. Of course it is. And it is not whether the objectives of the Directives should be weakened. Of course not. The question is a practical one: Can we achieve the objectives of the Nature Directives more effectively, more efficiently, and more simply — while maintaining their level of ambition and high level of protection? Our simplification agenda aims to deliver clear, understandable rules and coherent procedures. It seeks to ensure that data can be used more effectively. And that people are not buried in unnecessary, complex administration. The stress test is now being finalised. We have received extensive feedback from Member States, stakeholders, practitioners and citizens. And much of that input has converged around the two themes that will be discussed today. On Natura 2000 and land use, we have heard concerns about the administrative burden, especially related to forestry and agriculture. But we have also heard constructive proposals from Member States and stakeholders. For example, stakeholders have pointed to the need for clearer procedures, better guidance, more accessible data, sufficient funding, better planning and cooperation, and more proportionate and efficient implementation. It also means recognising that Natura 2000 is a living, breathing network, much of it shaped by long- standing human activity and careful land management. That is why practical solutions, local knowledge and early dialogue matter so much. I hear a lot about the challenges related to forestry in Natura 2000 sites in the context of climate change. I want to assure you that we are listening, we understand the difficulties facing this sector, and we take them very seriously. I also want to reassure you that the Habitats Directive allows for habitat transformation. Climate change, including wildfire risks, can and should be taken into account in setting favourable reference values, conservation objectives and measures. If that needs further clarification, we will provide it. The aim is to develop healthy, biodiverse forest habitats – because they are more resilient to climate hazards. And as such, they boost the long term productivity and resilience of the forestry sector. The second issue — species protection and rural livelihoods — has also generated a lot of input. And here too, the message has been clear. Europeans support nature protection. But they also expect policies to be realistic, proportionate, and workable on the ground. This is especially important in rural areas. We have seen how the return or recovery of some protected species – like the Barnacle goose, the Great Cormorant, the Rook or the bear – can bring ecological benefits, but also challenges for farmers, foresters, fishers and local communities. Our world, climate and environment are changing rapidly. And sometimes, such population increases reflect wider ecosystem imbalances. It means that we cannot view locally increasing populations in isolation. We need to look at them in the broader context of ecosystem health and biodiversity trends. These are complex questions. And our response needs to be balanced, science-based and adaptive. Our objective must be to reconcile the conservation of wild birds and other species with legitimate socio-economic interests. And we need to do so while restoring the ecological balance and resilience of our ecosystems. Ladies and gentlemen, This hearing is an opportunity to test ideas and compare experiences. We need to identify what works, what can be improved, and what can be scaled up. For example, is there a way to make the listing of species more dynamic? To adapt it to changing conditions and evolving population trends? Another question. How can we make the assessment of projects simpler and more efficient? But whatever decisions we make, we need ensure that the Nature Directives are as effective, efficient and impactful as possible – for the sake of our economy, our environment, and our future. Now, I look forward to/wish you an insightful, constructive discussion. SPEECH/26/2519